The Podcast Industry's Unreached Audience Is on YouTube and Facebook — It Just Doesn't Know It Yet
This piece is freely available to read. Become a paid subscriber today and help keep Podwires financially afloat so that we can continue to pay our writers for their insight and expertise.
Podwires Rundown: Twenty-five per cent of American adults have never listened to a podcast. Not a clip. Not a YouTube video; they didn’t realise it was a show. Nothing. The industry has largely written these people off as unreachable—older, low-income, media-resistant. Tom Webster spent time with the data and found something more complicated. Most of them aren’t rejecting podcasting. They just haven’t been invited yet. Here’s the uncomfortable part: the invitation the industry keeps sending is written in the wrong language, delivered on the wrong platform, and leading with the wrong pitch.
Source note: This piece draws from “The Last Quarter”, a new research report from Sounds Profitable, authored by Tom Webster and presented at Podcast Movement Evolutions at SXSW. The study draws from the Podcast Landscape survey of more than 5,000 Americans, weighted to the U.S. Census. Sounds Profitable is a podcast industry research and consulting firm with commercial relationships across the industry. The full report is available for direct download via Sounds Profitable. Flag the vendor context—but Webster’s methodology and track record are well-established.
The Key Points
61% of podcast holdouts are 55 or older, and 58% are women—a demographic that skews heavily towards older females, with a significant concentration of 70-plus adults who have simply never been meaningfully reached by the medium.
88% of holdouts know the word “podcast”—the awareness problem is largely solved; the barrier is misperception, not ignorance, with many believing podcasting is audio-only and not understanding its video dimension.
57% of holdouts are already on YouTube, making it the most underutilised on-ramp in podcasting’s non-listener conversion toolkit.
Facebook dominates this demographic’s social media behaviour by a margin far greater than any other segment measured—Instagram sits at 36% and LinkedIn at 14%, and the gap between Facebook and everything else is wider here than anywhere else in the data.
The three conversion barriers are attention competition, education gaps, and format resistance—in that order—with the middle cluster (people who don’t understand what podcasting is or think it costs money) identified as the most actionable and correctable group.
Why It Matters
The podcast industry has spent the last decade growing by reaching people who were already ready to listen. That growth runway is narrowing. The remaining 25% of non-listeners isn’t a monolithic wall of resistance—it’s a segmented group with specific, identifiable barriers, many of which are correctable with targeted education and smarter channel strategy. Webster’s data suggests that chasing this audience with technology messaging and celebrity pitches will fail. Leading with utility—something useful to hear on your commute, something to learn while you walk—is what actually moves the needle. The medium doesn’t need a rebrand. It needs a different conversation with a different audience, on platforms it has largely ignored.
The Big Picture
For podcasters: YouTube isn’t just a distribution play for your existing audience—it’s the most realistic bridge to non-listeners who are already there and could stumble into your content before they ever consciously decide to “try podcasting”. Optimise YouTube for discoverability, not just consumption. And if your show has any relevance to Spanish-speaking audiences, the data flags a real, underserved opportunity: 48% of Hispanic and Latino holdouts are primarily Spanish-proficient, and local Spanish-language content is specifically called out as a gap worth filling.
For podcast producers: The car remains the most important unconquered territory. Webster’s data identifies commute and travel utility as a top conversion trigger—and yet the industry’s marketing rarely leads with it. Producers advising creators on growth strategy should be building car-listening into content architecture: clean audio, strong episode openers, and no visual-dependent segments that leave audio-only listeners behind.
For the industry: The strategic play here is radio. AM/FM broadcast still indexes strongly with holdouts, and streaming audio on radio is declining, which means there’s an audience actively searching for an alternative they don’t yet know exists. Targeted ad buys in small and mid-sized markets promoting podcast content through radio isn’t a retro idea. It’s the most direct line from where this audience already is to where the industry needs them to go. The correctable gap isn’t awareness. It’s the invitation itself—and the industry keeps sending the wrong one.
Not ready to be paid to subscribe, but appreciate the newsletter ? Grab us a beer or snag the exclusive ad spot at the top of next week's newsletter.
